Showing posts with label James Fenimore Cooper. Show all posts
Showing posts with label James Fenimore Cooper. Show all posts

Monday, January 12, 2009

Natty Bumppo's "natur": The anxiety of bearing no cross

Illustration depicting the aged Natty Bumppo's first appearance, silhouetted against an enormous setting sun, in Cooper's The Prairie (1827). Image found here.

I know, I know: I said I was reading Cooper so you didn't have to. But no one said anything about shielding you from reading about Cooper.

Over at Domestic Issue there's a long post that meditates on the word and phrase you see in its title. What follows is the core of the post:

At the beginning of this post, I wondered whether, by rendering Bumppo’s pronunciation of the word as “natur,” Cooper might want to suggest something more existential about his protagonist: that he at some level feels some lack in his nature that puts him at risk of being alienated from the people with whom he claims a racial kinship. It’s here that I would like to engage in a bit more speculation: that the key to Bumppo’s anxiety is suggested by a pun, which may or may not be intentional on Cooper’s part, in Bumppo’s saying that his “blood bears no cross”: that is, that while Bumppo believes in God and “Providence,” it would be a mistake to identify him as a Christian–at least, as that term is understood by the other whites in the novel. At a time when religious affiliation, a community’s being held together and affirming its members via a shared faith in God–and, more precisely, a shared expression of that faith via theology and doctrine–was an accepted part of communal life and was fully embraced by almost everyone, it is not too excessive to suggest the possibility that Bumppo’s spiritual estrangement from his fellows compels him to affirm his kinship via his consanguinity–his “natur”–all the while fearing that even consanguinity might not be sufficient.
There's also a brief guest appearance by a naked and emaciated Cabeza de Vaca. Really now: How can you resist that teaser?

Read More...

Thursday, January 08, 2009

A pithy passage from Poirier

Thomas Cole, Scene from "The Last of the Mohicans," Cora Kneeling at the Feet of Tamenund. 1827. Wadsworth Atheneum Museum of Art. Click image to enlarge. Image found here.

From Richard Poirier's A World Elsewhere: The Place of Style in American Literature, as he winds up some commentary on Cooper's Natty Bumppo (referred to by Poirier as Deerslayer) before making some more general remarks about American literature of the 19th century:

At his most impressive, Deerslayer is a character described rather than self-articulated, a man seen by the narrator "communing . . . without the aids or forms of language" rather than a conversationalist[. . . .]

Other writers, like Thoreau, Melville, Mark Twain, James, and Faulkner, acknowledge how difficult it is to give authority to ideas, specifically those of the "poet" as the hero of relinquishment and possession, which are otherwise defenseless against the claims of conventional reality. Of course, any such comparative claims are tentative; one kind of accomplishment in literature is not all accomplishments, and in this instance Emerson and Cooper probably could have done fewer of the things they do so superbly had they been more stylistically defensive. Nonetheless, these other writers show greater willingness to make the investment by which a protective environment can be created for some of the images and themes they share with Emerson. In the complications of their language and in their structural ingenuities, they force the reader actually to participate in "the struggle for verbal consciousness" that is to liberate us from customary suppositions about the meaning of words like "possession" or "nature," "the poet" or "reality." Their best performances are known for their intricacy, their opaqueness, even to the point where they are discussed not as books but as "problems for interpretation." (pp.76-77)
There is much to tease out of this passage. The one thing I'll point to here, as I've noted before regarding Poirier's book, is his identifying the ultimately irresolvable tension in our literature's greatest novels between, on the one hand, the desire--the need?--to create and articulate an American Myth and, on the other, what Philip Fisher would later call the hard facts of American history.

Read More...

Tuesday, January 06, 2009

In which the Meridian reads Cooper so you don't have to (even though you should)

Natty Bumppo tells a sitting Uncas, "Look at me! I'm a white guy, and I still make a better Indian than you do!" Or something like that. Click to enlarge the image. Image found here.

Reading James Fenimore Cooper is one of the less-pleasurable lots of the specialist in American literature. It's not that we have to read lots and lots of Cooper (unless it's our fate to concentrate on the literature of the first half of the 19th century, or on any of various themes Cooper raises--a proto-environmentalism, Indian/settler relations (and race more generally), male/female relations, etc.); but, sooner or later, we must. The Leatherstocking Tales are indispensable reading for anyone who wants to get a sense of prevailing attitudes in this country regarding the themes I listed above, and Natty Bumppo, despite (or perhaps because of) his near-insufferable unctuousness, is our first truly American character.

I'm appreciative of all this. But while reading The Last of the Mohicans for book-project reasons, I feel Uncas' pain in the scene depicted above. Never mind where in the novel this scene occurs; it matters not. If Bumppo is in it, he will be disquisitioning on the subject he knows best: himself--or, more accurately, how his knowledge of the woods and the things in it is superior to that of everyone else (with the exception of Chingachgook, Uncas' father and the one person Bumppo consistently defers to in the novel).

The other thing Bumppo asserts with strange regularity is his racial purity. His blood "bears no cross," he says, almost like a mantra, often using that line either as a preface or as an epilogue to statements that, as often as not, have nothing to do with his or anyone else's race. Yet Bumppo, raised by the Lenai Lenappi from childhood, is culturally mixed even if his blood is not; thus, he is intriguing precisely when he is being most obnoxious. There's something very American, to me, in this tension between Bumppo's constant assertions of his racial purity and his simultaneous apparent blindness to the fact of his culturally-mixed heritage.

More later on this last bit. I just felt you should know that someone is looking out for you.

Read More...