Showing posts with label Pedagogy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pedagogy. Show all posts

Saturday, January 31, 2009

Writer's block: the paper

[EDIT: Welcome, visitors from Douglas and Main. Just a note of clarification: While I wrote about a brick, my students are free to choose for this exercise any object, photograph or short piece of music that, for whatever reason, they have in their possession and has meaning for them. If you're curious, this post has the assignment.]

As promised a couple of days ago, below the fold you'll find my effort, which I'll also share with the classes that have this assignment. The strange thing is that, even at 1257 words (you've been warned), it feels like it is less than it could be. The more one tries to describe, the more one begins to notice things.

I make no claims as to its merits, but I will say again that I'm very glad I both made the assignment and took it on myself. If I learned some things by virtue of having done it, I feel pretty confident that my students will, too.

I will be describing a brick. This brick measures 3 ½” high by 8 ½” wide by 3” deep and weighs 7 pounds and 8 ounces. Most of it is coated with a thick glaze, dark caramel in color. On two sides, though, the glaze is either missing or has been worn away. On one of those sides, the exposed clay is a red the color of iron that has just begun to glow from being heated. The other side also shows red clay, though its red is considerably darker. The brick’s longer edges are beveled. Some of its shorter edges appear to be beveled as well, but others are sharper edged. Its form is not perfectly rectangular: one of the 3 ½” x 3” ends is not quite perpendicular to the brick’s other planes; thus, when stood on that end the brick tilts slightly off what should be its true latitudinal axis.

The brick is mostly intact. Much of one corner is gone, and three other of its eight corners are chipped as well, though not nearly as much. A deep chipped groove almost bisects one of the 3” edges; other edges reveal smaller dings resulting from wear and weathering. One of the smaller corner chips reveals something not otherwise visible anywhere else on the brick: the clay appears layered, and a small piece of clay that protrudes from the bottom of the chip wiggles a little, like a loose tooth. Traces of grayish-white mortar remain on three of the brick’s six surfaces.

One of the 3 ½” x 8 ½” surfaces, which I will refer to for convenience’s sake as the front of the brick, features two raised ridges, one at each of the two narrow ends of the surface, and writing embossed into the surface. The ridges measure approximately 2” in length and are located about 1” from, and run parallel to, the 3 ½” edges. The ends of the ridges are about ¾” from the 8 ½” edges. The writing is centered in the large space between the ridges. It consists of three words, one word per line; the letters are approximately ½” tall and are all upper-case letters: “MESCH / PITTSBURG / BLOCK” The words PITTSBURG and BLOCK are difficult to read because mortar partially or almost completely fills many of the letters of these words. The upper-left corner of this face is the most damaged of the brick’s eight corners. The chipped portion forms a rough right-triangle measuring approximately 2” x 1 ½” x 2 ¾”. At its lowest point, the chip is about a quarter-inch below the surface. The hypotenuse of this triangle just grazes the end of the ridge closest to it. Tilting the brick at just the right angle reveals that about halfway along the 1 ½” edge of this chip (the side on the upper edge) there is a small piece of a mineral that reflects back a bright-red light. The lower-left corner of the face is also chipped, though the damaged area is smaller and more irregularly-shaped.

From here, I will describe the remaining three larger surfaces, rotating the brick so that the surface on which the brick has so far been resting becomes the next surface to be described. Thus, the next surface is the 3” x 8 ½” surface that is perpendicular to the front’s bottom edge (that is, it is closer to the word BLOCK). It is distinct from the others in that it is pocked with numerous small cavities of various shapes, sizes and depths more or less evenly distributed across the surface (the other surfaces, by comparison, are remarkably smooth). The majority of these cavities are lighter in color than either the red clay or the caramel-colored glaze. None of these cavities is very deep, and no cracks radiate from any of them. This side has no visible traces of the dark caramel glaze on its surface. One of the larger pocks, located at the right end of the surface, stands out from the others because it is filled almost to the surface with a very dark material that does not appear to be clay; around the edge of this dark material appears a hairline gap between it and the space within which it rests.

The reverse of the brick is the 3 ½” x 8 ½” surface on the side opposite that which contains the ridges and writing described earlier. Its surface is the smoothest of the brick’s larger surfaces. Some thin traces of mortar appear on this surface. Under strong light, one can see that the dark caramel glaze coats only about a third of this surface and, indeed, is quite thin here as compared to its apparent thickness on the brick’s other surfaces. A shallow concave chip measuring a little over 1” at its widest appears near the exact center of the upper 8 ½” edge; near the upper-right corner, there is a shallow notch at the base of which appears a hairline crack--one of the few genuine cracks appearing anywhere on this brick.

The fourth and last of the larger surfaces is the second 3” x 8 ½” surface. This surface’s roughness results from the combination of a very uneven coat of glaze and two large chips of material missing from its left and bottom edges. The glaze has formed ridges on this surface, one running more or less parallel to and about ¾” from the left side, the other running at a slight angle to and along almost the entire length of the bottom side. At its most prominent point, this second ridge protrudes about 1/8” above the surface. These ridges reveal that the glaze is not of uniform composition but contains bits of lighter-colored material within it, a fact not revealed by those surfaces where the glaze is intact. The exposed brick on this surface is that which is the color of heated iron that I mentioned in the first paragraph.

To the left of and perpendicular to this surface is the first of the 3 ½” x 3” surfaces I will describe. This surface’s right edge and lower-right corner bear considerable damage--these correspond to, respectively, the left edge and lower-left corner of the surface described in the above paragraph. In addition, the lower-left corner is chipped, and the entirety of the top edge shows damage from wear and weathering. A large clump of mortar and two smaller clumps appear on this side as well; the large clump is on the surface‘s right-center, and below it the smaller clumps serve as two points on a line almost exactly parallel to the bottom edge, thus forming a triangle with the large clump serving as its apex.

The reverse 3 ½” x 3” surface, which forms the perpendicular to the right edge of the front of the brick, has chipped upper-left and lower-right corners as its most distinctive features. The lower-right corner almost appears, from this perspective, as though it had been cleaved off; the chipped portion follows the left edge to about the halfway point of that edge. The chip at the upper-left corner, though, spreads chiefly in the direction of the surface’s center up to about an inch at its longest point. The lower quarter of this surface has a few pocks. What appears at first to be a long hairline crack located about a third of the way down from the top edge proves, on closer inspection, to be a space where the clay simply didn’t quite fill the form prior to firing.


Read More...

Monday, January 19, 2009

"You're not looking!!!" Part II

The previous post was a bit sketchier than I had intended.

Here, very briefly, are the sorts of assignments I have in mind that will build on what I described here (the order subject to change):

#2a--Narration: Relate some story connected to the object you described in paper #1. Some possibilities: the story of how it came to be in your possession; (if it's a photograph) the story of the event documented in the picture, or a story about a person in the picture; (if it's a song) the story of how it came to be meaningful for you, or a narrative suggested by the song's lyrics or, even, melody; (if it's a painting) create a narrative suggested by the scene depicted in the painting. The one requirement is that the narrative you write have the object as its starting place.

#2b--Process: If you made the object in question, describe the procedure for either how you made that particular object or how one would go about making other objects like it.

#3--Compare-Contrast: What are some of the similarities and differences between this object and another, comparable object? This other object, by the way, doesn't have to be in your possession, but you need to be very familiar with it in order to do this assignment well.

#4--Division/Classification: Your object is unique unto itself, yet we're able to identify it as something because it shares characteristics with other, more or less similar objects. Those other objects, however, have attributes that allow us to say they are different in degree from others (as one simple example, my brick is a paving brick; what distinguishes them from bricks used for buildings are their weight and their one large, smooth side). What systems of classification (large groupings within a general area, such as "Visual Art"'s containing the classifications of Painting, Sculpture, Photography, and Film) or division (categories within a classification: "Photography" contains the divisions of daguerrotype, film, and digital) does your object participate in? Describe those classifications/divisions, being sure to provide examples for illustrative purposes.

#5--Cause-Effect: This one I admit to having some troubles with regarding the nature of the assignment. Good thing it comes toward the end of the semester, eh?

#6--Argument: This one could head in any number of directions, some only distantly related to, though traceable back to, the object in question. In the case of my brick, for example: it was part of the fill used for the small levee along the Little Arkansas. Infrastructure issues, such as the merits vs. the liabilities of brick streets in "age-appropriate" parts of cities; the future of water use in the area: those are two topics that immediately come to mind. A family photograph might suggest to someone a course of action s/he (or someone else) might take with regard to some issue that someone in the picture is facing. By this point in the semester, my students will have spent so much time thinking and writing about these objects and things associated with them that they should have all sorts of ideas floating about that can possibly work here. I'm not looking on think tank-quality policy statements here, just some evidence that the wheels are in motion.

As with the previous post, comments are welcome.

Read More...

"You're not looking!!: A possible (sequence of) writing assignment(s)

By Leonardo Da Vinci. Click to enlarge. Image found here.

Many of my students are fond of saying that they like to get "right to the point" in their writing. While in some instances that's an admirable trait, I don't think it's one that they are consciously striving to achieve--it's reflective of either a hurry-up-and-get-it-over-with attitude regarding the assignment (this also reveals itself via a preoccupation with word or page counts) or, more likely--and sadly--a genuine lack of practice in developing their ideas. Whichever the case, these mindsets not only are not helpful ones to have when confronting many if not most writing assignments for college courses, they also produce dull, even lifeless writing . . . and puzzlement, not to say frustration, for students who get their papers back with queries from their instructor such as "Can you develop this more?" or (in the case of narratives, where the problems with this mindset really reveal themselves), "Where is this happening?" or "Who are these people?" or, in literary analysis papers, "Where in the text does this idea come from?", etc.

I'm going to be more optimistic here and say that what my students lack is, first, practice in closely observing something and then writing about it, and second, making connections between the particular and the general (as opposed to often mistaking the former for the latter). So, I've begun working out a series of interrelated assignments for my Comp I students that should give them practice in both these areas, sketched out below the fold. Feedback always welcome, by the way.

I usually give my students a range of options for each assignment, but this first one, tentatively titled, "You're not looking!!!", will be mandatory. If you're at all curious, it's inspired in large measure by the bit in this post about the brick, which will also serve as my demonstration for the assignment. And speaking of bricks, I also have in mind a moment from Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance when Pirsig, frustrated with a student who isn't terribly imaginative, tells her to write an essay about the facade of the opera house downtown--specifically, to begin by describing one of the bricks in the facade--and she responds by writing a paper far in excess of the required length.

[Note to self: Yes, Pirsig eventually went nuts, but I don't that was attributable to teaching Freshman Comp.

The things we tell ourselves.]

I'll work out the precise wording later, but the essence will be this:

Choose an object--not a machine or device or animal or person--that, for whatever reason, you have around you and, for whatever reason, inspires curiosity in you or has meaning for you. The object can be any self-contained 3-dimensional entity, preferably one without moving parts, a photograph, a painting, or a song (the song can be part of a larger work, but it shouldn't itself contain multiple sections, such as a concerto or symphony).

Describe this object. Don't tell how it came to be in your possession or relate its significance to you or compare it to other, similar objects. Describe it. In the case of photographs and paintings, where are people/objects it depicts located in relation to each other, and what do those things look like? In the case of songs, remember that songs exist most fully when performed and thus exist in time as well as in space; also, if the song has lyrics, quote but do not interpret them.

Minimum length: 1000 words, firm. Papers shorter than this will not fulfill the assignment, period. You are, of course, welcome and encouraged to write more (that's what "minimum" implies, after all)--if you feel the need to write more in order to describe your object, by all means do so. In any case: start early!
Something like that.

The word-length requirement is a big deal for me: it's the first time I've ever set a specific requirement like that for a writing assignment. The goal is to get them to write more than than most of them would be likely to write and, paradoxically, get at least some of them to see that what will seem like an awful lot of words initially will in fact prove to be inadequate.

(He says as he crosses his pedagogical fingers.)

Here's what I'm thinking: I hope my students will a) gain a little practice in paying attention to what they see and/but b) an object in isolation, devoid of context, is semantically inert (that's a point, by way of analogy, that I want to get across when I talk about maps and GPS units on the first day). I hope they'll feel a little frustration by being restricted to description, that they'll spend a little time thinking about the fact that these things acquire meaning only in association with something/someone else. That's where the other rhetorical modes--narration, division/classification, cause-effect, compare-contrast--and argument will come in.

If this were the best of all possible pedagogical worlds, I'd insist that all their subsequent writing assignments be linked in some way to this object they've chosen. Those assignments would contain suggestions, but the starting place would be the object they use for the first paper. But I can't quite insist, especially when, as I've been thinking about my brick, I've had a bit of trouble coming up with one or two possible subjects for papers that would fulfill the assignment. But then again, I want them to be imaginative, to not take the easy way out. I also suspect that lots of possibilities will suggest themselves as they work on that first paper.

Comments?

Read More...

Friday, December 05, 2008

Greg House runs a differential on public education: a thought-experiment

"I said, Relax your sphincter and tell me how you'd fix that fragment! If you can't, the sentence dies. I don't hold out much academic hope for you, either."

Image found here.


Last night, I subbed for a colleague after watching four straight episodes from the first season of House M.D. I even wore jeans and tennis shoes and didn't shave my two-days' beard, though I realized how I looked only afterward. No cane, though, you'll be relieved to learn. Let's just say that I'm not sure that, at one level, watching House positively contributed to my classroom demeanor. In class, I found myself fighting off the tendency to be sarcastic and cutting with these nice people I'd never seen before and most likely would not see again. But it occurs to me this morning that, absent complete instructions provided by the regular prof, a sub is indeed something like a diagnostician--assuming, of course, the sub wants that time with the class to matter . . . and, given that the class started at 7:30 p.m., I wanted to be more than the educational equivalent of "a monkey with a bottle of Motrin"--House's memorable description of the competence required of doctors working in his hospital's walk-in clinic. So, by golly, we weren't just going to fix these sentences from student papers that the prof had turned into a worksheet; we were going to review the mechanics--the rules--that explained the fixes. Mechanics do indeed matter: they are the governing rules for language that allow us to comprehend anything at all. And besides, it's my understanding that in Kansas public schools reviews of mechanics pretty much end after middle school. Reviewing them, therefore, is usually a useful thing at the college level--they are the "diet and exercise" of effective writing. So, in the end, I got to say some things to the class similar to what House gets to say in most every episode: "You're not looking!" "You're missing something." "'It just sounds right' is not a rule!"

It was a good class, I thought. A couple of students even thanked me for teaching them something. "Cool," as House might have said.

Actually, I wish House would run a differential on public education. What would his diagnosis (or diagnoses) be? I suspect, given his antagonistic stance relative to his hospital's administration, that he'd a) be the first to agree with any proposal that streamlines the bureaucracy and moves to get rid of deadwood and incompetence, so long as b) the schools' first priorities, providing quality instruction and ensuring that students learn what they need to be learning, are enhanced or at least not interfered with. But if the proposals addressing (a), however well intentioned, end up satisfying some accrediting or funding body but impairing (b), better not to do (a), then. No Child Left Behind, to my mind, is the poster child for a well-intentioned but ultimately educationally-dysfunctional and, perhaps, harmful reform.

Along these lines, yesterday I ran across two different but intriguing posts on the general subject of "What ails public education?" My bloggy friend Randall of Musings from the Hinterland responds to a recent op-ed in the Wall Street Journal in which a former CEO of IBM argues that the problem is a lack of standardization among school districts, which leads to inefficiencies in the education system. Meanwhile, Matthew Yglesias links to a report from the Center for American Progress that notes a correlation between teacher tenure policies and the poor quality of instruction in high-poverty districts. As I read these pieces, I found myself saying, "Yeah, but." All of us can sign on to the ideas of greater bureaucratic efficiency and improving teacher quality. But what do we have if we have excellent teachers who are given watered-down material to teach--they're teaching it well, but it ends up not being terribly nourishing intellectually for the student? Have we "fixed" public education by setting and agreeing on standards of achievement if the material mastered is thin gruel and, for that matter, if those standards are set not for reasons of pedagogy but to determine a school's funding?

In other words: I'd argue for any educational reform whose ultimate goal is not to save some administrator's ass but to improve what happens in the classroom. We've fixed nothing--or, rather, we've not fixed what really matters--if all we've done is improved the efficiency with which we deliver ultimately inadequate information to students. Cigarette smoke is still toxic, whether second-hand or inhaled directly.

When talking about argument, I sometimes use the following factoid as a set-up for a thought-experiment: The California Department of Corrections estimates its future space requirements for state prisons in part by looking at the number of 4th graders who cannot read at a 4th-grade level. (When I tell my students this, they are often stunned into silence.) Then I ask them, What are some things we can conclude from this fact, especially as regards the importance of being competent readers? And, more to the point, what can or should schools do that they aren't doing now to better ensure reading competency?

Some further thoughts on this, along with a proposal, below the fold.

As one advances in school, reading becomes the one skill central to the acquisition of knowledge needed for mastery of subject matter and skills; yet, formal instruction in reading tends to end in the 4th grade. The assumption has traditionally been that from that point on students will continue to grow and improve as readers as they read their textbooks. Would that that assumption were in fact true. The fact that California's Department of Corrections makes projections about its future space needs by looking at the reading levels of 4th-graders, it seems to me, is an implicit recognition of another truth: if kids aren't reading at their grade level by 4th grade, they are unlikely to improve enough on their own to keep up with those of their peers who are: the needed instruction and encouragement just won't be there. The results: Many of those kids will end up dropping out of school; those who don't will somehow get by in high school but then either show up at colleges like mine and be expected to read and comprehend college-level texts with 6th-grade reading levels, or they'll struggle to read things like, oh, lease agreements or terms and conditions statements on credit applications, etc.; and some will end up getting into trouble of various sorts that may necessitate prison time.

Here's what I tell my students: if they can read well, they can teach themselves anything--what they want to know is written down, somewhere. There's no more practical skill needed for success in formal education and/or in the Real World than reading.

If we want to improve overall student performance, we should make reading proficiency an educational priority from K-12. Maybe extend formal reading instruction up till 8th grade. Or, test kids' reading levels at various points in their K-12 careers, and if, after 4th grade, they're found not to be reading within, say, four grade levels of where they actually are in school, get them some extra instruction. Don't allow kids to receive their high school diplomas until/unless they can demonstrate they're reading at or above an 8th-grade level, regardless of their credits earned. And whatever we do, we shouldn't tie a school's or a district's funding to the percentage of kids reading above or below their grade level, except for reasons of paying for salaries and materials for needed reading instructors, testing, etc. That way, the emphasis is on individual students' performance, and (I'd think) the goal becomes getting them to become proficient at the highest possible level. It also would reduce outside pressure on administrators of the sort they're presently under because of NCLB: if a certain percentage of kids don't graduate because they can't satisfy the proficiency requirement, it's those kids who are punished by not receiving their diplomas until they can. The schools--not to mention future students--aren't hurt, but they'll still have the resources to get them up to snuff. But here's the thing: if schools are pushing and testing for reading proficiency throughout students' careers, in theory the number of students not reading at level will be smaller and smaller in the higher grade levels.

"Yet more testing!?" you're saying. My thinking, though, is that in view of reading's centrality to formal learning, a prioritizing of measuring reading proficiency would lead to an eventual reduction in the number of standardized tests kids take these days. Reading proficiency tests, after all, are measuring comprehension, and the material being comprehended has to be about something, doesn't it? In other words, if kids are shown to be reading at their grade level, they are by definition comprehending--demonstrating mastery of--the subject at hand. Even better: "teaching to the test" is exactly what you'd want teachers to be doing in the case of testing for reading proficiency. The goal is to get kids reading at a level somewhere near their grade level. So ideally, this wouldn't have to be the sort of test you review or prepare for; daily emphasis on reading proficiency in every subject would be enough. Moreover, any class in any subject could serve as a potential opportunity for testing and reinforcing reading proficiency. Higher emphasis on reading proficiency should also help with developing higher-order kinds of thinking, as well.

Much as I would love to legislate that parents read to their kids from the moment of conception till they can read on their own, I recognize that, alas, we live in a free society. But it may also be that schools' emphasis on reading proficiency will encourage more parents, regardless of socioeconomic status, to promote reading at home, too. Hey--a boy can hope, eh?

I'm sure I'm overlooking something here from a pedagogical standpoint. My background isn't in reading instruction. What I do know, though, is that I see students who have decent grades from high school and want to do well in college but struggle and can't understand why. More often than not, it's because they are underprepared as readers and, moreover, we've recently begun requiring especially-deficient readers to take reading classes. But even if these students weren't going on to college, they'd still be underprepared for life beyond school because of their poor reading proficiency. Either way, they've been ill-served by an educational system whose members and critics seem more focused on what are ultimately administrative rather than pedagogical or content issues. An insisting on grade-appropriate reading proficiency would focus attention where it should be--on the individual's educational attainment and preparation for whatever lies ahead for them beyond graduation . . . and maybe we wouldn't have to plan to build quite so many prison cells.

Read More...

Thursday, October 23, 2008

Welcome, and some initial comments on blogs as a teaching tool

Greetings to my Comp II students who may have found their way here. If you have some time, I encourage you to poke around to see some of the things I'm interested in--a good place to begin is with "Assemblages," over in the right-hand gutter.

And to regular visitors: I'm still officially on sabbatical, but I'll be teaching a class during this second half of the semester to earn a little extra money and to test drive a couple of things I'm interested in incorporating in my classes in the spring.

The big experiment is that I'm requiring these students to set up and maintain blogs connected in some way to the subjects they choose for their research projects. Writing teachers can yammer about the importance of accounting for audience in their writing all they want, but so long as that writing remains caught within the vacuum of the classroom, their sole "audience" someone who because of his job requirements has to read and comment on their work (that includes peer review, too, by the way), audience remains more an abstraction than something actively to be contended with as they write. So, I thought that their setting up blogs to write about the research they've done and what they think about it might be a way to get them to think about audience from the get-go. Also, since I'm requiring students to post links to pertinent sites and to list their blogs with a couple of directories, I hope that people who share their interests will find their blogs and leave comments. Indeed, as they get them set up, I'll be posting links to their blogs here so that, if you wish, you can go visit them.

[Aside: One thing that occurs to me as I sit here is that I'm not (yet) sure whether the essential blankness of a blog's audience--what I mean by that is that a blog's writer has no prior knowledge of the persons who visit his/her blog; that can only occur over time and if/when/as they comment on posts--is a good or a bad thing. It's my hope that, due to my requiring them to list their blogs in directories, most people who visit them will have some interest in their subjects; but beyond that, they can't presume too much. This, of course, is where discussions of "audience" in the abstract will come in handy.]

We'll see how it goes. I sensed a fair amount of trepidation (usual symptom: near-complete silence) as I have talked about this in class, but I think that it'll work as I want it to . . . most of that "work," of course, occurring beneath the surface as those difficult-to-measure things that nevertheless add up to the je ne sais quoi of Good Writing. While we wait to see what will come of all this, I have some questions for those of you who teach or, in Randall's case, cohabit with one or, in Pam's case, guide research: Do you have students use blogs as a pedagogical tool? Do you have colleagues who do? If so, how? What sort of luck (good or bad--I need to know pitfalls as well as views from the mountantops) have you/they had them? If you're interested in what I'm requiring of them, e-mail me and I'll send you what appears in the syllabus.

________
UPDATE: For some reason this morning, Blogger is not letting me post comments on my own blog. Here, then, is my response to Pam's comment:

Pam,
If you're worried about rambling on my blog, you've not been reading with nearly enough attention.

There's a big debate going on in the humanities as well about the place of blogs relative to traditional notions of academic work. I personally (still) err on the side of tradition myself. As you know, I have an "academic" blog where I write about more scholarly preoccupations. In the book project, I'll mention it in the acknowledgments as a place out of which some ideas and content emerged in the book proper, but to jump from that to claiming that that it's a resource on a par with, even, an article in a refereed journal strikes me as, well, presumptuous.

I think of the blog as an electronic version of thinking out loud: a space for speculation, for trying out ideas, and for those who find it and are interested to weigh in, but by no means a finished product.

It's in that sense that I'm pointing my students with regard to their blogs. They still are required to turn in finished, formal papers. I confess that it's also a ploy to make sure that they are doing some initial engaging with sources, as well as with a potential audience, as they write, and not just dumping everything into a paper the night or two before it's due. That's the stick; the carrot, for me if not for them, is that I'm hoping that it will result in better writing--which is to say, a better quality of thinking as reflected in their writing.

Writing in the sciences, I imagine, is more about reporting on the results of having tested hypotheses than on the generating of those hypotheses; yet (as I've seen in your blog), surely the generating of those ideas is crucial to science as well. Perhaps that's an appropriate space for blogs for researchers in the sciences?

Read More...