Showing posts with label Wallace Stevens. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Wallace Stevens. Show all posts

Thursday, October 02, 2008

Wallace Stevens

Image found here.

Today is Wallace Stevens' birthday. Long-time visitors here know that Stevens' work is an important touchstone for this blog, so I would be remiss if I didn't post a little something in honor of this man on his day.

Below the fold: a couple of links to past posts of mine in which Stevens figures prominently, along with a poem of his.

First the posts, which also happen to be among the more commented-upon posts I've written:

A stretch of river XXXIX: Updating the wildlife census, and some thoughts on this blog's epigraph

Nothing that is not there, and the nothing that is: A ramble through "the natural world"

And now the poem: a small but important poem for reading him, Stevens' "Tea at the Palaz of Hoon" (text found here):

Not less because in purple I descended
The western day through what you called
The loneliest air, not less was I myself.

What was the ointment sprinkled on my beard?
What were the hymns that buzzed beside my ears?
What was the sea whose tide swept through me there?

Out of my mind the golden ointment rained,
And my ears made the blowing hymns they heard.
I was myself the compass of that sea:

I was the world in which I walked, and what I saw
Or heard or felt came not but from myself;
And there I found myself more truly and more strange.

Read More...

Wednesday, January 02, 2008

Nothing that is not there and the nothing that is: A ramble through "the natural world"

Pooh and Piglet, "tracking something." Also titled, "How the Meridian comes to write some of his blog posts." (Originally found here)

By way of beginning, here's an excerpt from the chapter from which this illustration comes:

One fine winter's day when Piglet was brushing away the snow in front of his house, he happened to look up, and there was Winnie-the-Pooh. Pooh was walking round and round in a circle, thinking of something else, and when Piglet called to him, he just went on walking.

"Hallo!" said Piglet, "what are you doing?"

"Hunting," said Pooh.

"Hunting what?"

"Tracking something," said Winnie-the-Pooh very mysteriously.

"Tracking what?" said Piglet, coming closer.

"That's just what I ask myself. I ask myself, What?"

"What do you think you'll answer?"

"I shall have to wait until I catch up with it," said Winnie-the-Pooh. "Now, look there." He pointed to the ground in front of him. "What do you see there?"

"Tracks," said Piglet. "Paw-marks." He gave a little squeak of excitement. "Oh, Pooh! Do you think it's a -- a -- a Woozle?"

"It may be," said Pooh. "Sometimes it is, and sometimes it isn't. You never can tell with paw-marks."

With these few words he went on tracking, and Piglet, after watching him for a minute or two, ran after him. Winnie-the-Pooh had come to a sudden stop, and was bending over the tracks in a puzzled sort of way.

"What's the matter?" asked Piglet.

"It's a very funny thing," said Bear, "but there seem to be two animals now. This -- whatever-it-was -- has been joined by another -- whatever-it-is -- and the two of them are now proceeding in company. Would you mind coming with me, Piglet, in case they turn out to be Hostile Animals?"

Piglet scratched his ear in a nice sort of way, and said that he had nothing to do until Friday, and would be delighted to come, in case it really was a Woozle.

"You mean, in case it really is two Woozles," said Winnie-the-Pooh, and Piglet said that anyhow he had nothing to do until Friday. So off they went together.
(Just for the record: I bear no resemblance whatsoever to these two, as I have nothing to do until January 14.)

"Tracking" reveals its double meaning in this little scene: Pooh and Piglet track (follow) the Woozle, and they at the same time track (mark) the snow. What they regard and fear as a future unknown is really retrospection, a surveying of the past of their own ma(r)king. We recognize this because we are observing their world--we are outside their matrix (to borrow a term); they, of course, cannot, because they are giving shape to very world they are seeking to make sense of--one, moreover, that they assume they are somehow not affecting by virtue of their presence. Indeed, it's not too much to say that their assumed position relative to their world is exactly that of our actual position relative to theirs.

But it doesn't do to be too smug here. Sometimes--maybe most all the time--it is really ourselves we are tracking in the world, and we just don't recognize it. The phrase "natural world" is a sort of tracking-by-negation (or perhaps "denial"): embedded in it is the assumption that humans are fundamentally "unnatural."

This "ramble," as this post's title calls it, is about "tracking," very broadly defined.

At my previous place of employ, it so happened that outside one of the buildings where I taught a lot of my classes there were three young oak trees which, by some freak of nature (they weren't put there by a human agency), just happened to form a precise line (or precise enough for my purposes)--and, moreover, the space between trees 1 and 2 was almost exactly that of the space between trees 2 and 3: about 7' in each case. These trees came in extremely handy at that point in the semester when it came time to teach Wallace Stevens. Stevens' big theme is that the "imagination" is that which allows us to speak of what we observe in the world. For Stevens, there is a material world, and there is what we say about that world, but because language (broadly defined) is the means by which we speak of it and besides (for Stevens) has its origin with humans, there is always a bit of uncertainty as to whether what we say about it is in fact what is actually there independent of our perceiving it.

Enter those trees: As we'd go out and move among them I would ask my students, That we observe them as forming a line and being equidistant from their neighbors, are those observations the result of a set of ordering principles--in this case, those of Euclidean geometry--almost reflexively applied to what we're observing, or is that what is in fact true about them, independent of our making those observations? Sure: those observations "fit" what's in front of us; but how can we be certain that our observations are in fact what there was to observe? Maybe what we're "seeing" isn't an actual relationship involving those trees but only what our various languages allow us to express regarding them--even, perhaps, a subconscious product of our (human) desire to perceive an order regarding them: Stevens' "blessed rage for order . . . /The maker's rage to order . . . ("The Idea of Order at Key West"). But how to know, really know, what is really there? The stubborn, material, concrete thereness of these trees and their positions relative to each other and, simultaneously, our collective realization that whatever we "said" about them--whether verbally or through mathematics or some other means--originated with us and not with the trees themselves, worked perfectly (to my mind) to introduce Stevens' themes, to begin to make sense, for example, of his poem "The Snow Man," his attempt to describe what is required of us to truly "see" the world (assuming that is even possible): to "[behold]/Nothing that is not there, and the nothing that is."

Stevens wasn't a scientist. His "day job," as he himself phrased it, was helping to run an insurance company. But, given his preoccupation with the theme of observation and how the frame(s) of language(s) at our disposal cannot help but shape observation, he'd be a poet I'd quickly recommend to any scientist who thinks seriously about the relationship between the observer and what s/he observes--specifically, the extent to which the observer is really observing himself/herself.

Below the fold: "the natural world," within a Stevensian context.

What got me to thinking about that phrase most recently was this post by my bloggy friend Pam of Tales from the Microbial Lab. Pam's thing is microbes--at least, she makes her living by studying them and writing grant proposals to put some of our tax dollars to work in studying them some more. But her other thing is poetry. And gardening. And her two dogs and a cat. And building a new house to LEED standards while living in an Airstream travel trailer. She mixes all that up into her gumbo of a blog and makes it well worth her readers' time to keep going back for more. Anyway, you'll want to read her whole post, but here's the passage that got me to thinking about the phrase "the natural world" as she reflects on both her attempt earlier in the day to save a bird from a hawk and the question of how pathogens found in humans were also showing up in the respiratory tracts of dolphins (the italics are hers):
The questions have distracted me.

Why are you finding organisms in dolphins that are similar to those associated with humans?

How did the bottlenose dolphins become infected with human pathogens?

Is the antibiotic resistance of the dolphin microorganisms due to exposure to antibiotics from humans?

Questions, that in my conversation with several individuals today, kept getting me off-track. I knew differently, intuitively, but I nonetheless encouraged these conversations. So as I read some tonight, I was feeling awkward - and then I realized that I needed to shed these questions, dead-end questions, that everyone was asking, to shed the day's conversations, and come up with my own question and internal dialogue.

So I thought about my response this morning, my rush to save the captured bird - as you all know, as I have trouble accepting, the hawk was just doing what a hawk does. I could have just as easily cheered the hawk on, been relieved that it had captured it's lunch - my perspective was just skewed and biased.

It is much more likely that we humans have dolphin microorganisms associated with us.

Reading that prompted me to comment, in part,
[P]erhaps the a priori assumption for some hypotheses shouldn't be, "How have people screwed things up?" (e.g., the assumption that these dolphin pathogens originated in humans) but something more along the lines of "Is this something that actually confirms our connection to the 'natural world'?" (and it just struck me that that phrase "natural world" presumes or implies that humans are somehow "unnatural").

"Natural world" is one of those phrases that for most people, I suspect, just sort of rolls on past, an unremarkable, taken-for-granted expression of something. But of what? What is implicit in its taken-for-grantedness? I answer my question above, of course, in my comment on Pam's post, but I'd like to do a little teasing out of things here, using Stevens (and Pooh and Piglet) as contexts.

"Natural" is an adjective or, more generally, a qualifier: a word that delineates, that measures; a descriptor. We know, in a way that feels instinctive, what "natural" means in this particular usage: something that is pure, uninterfered with by humans. Indeed, the phrase's very existence implies human beings' felt or assumed disconnectedness from the world (one of the defining characteristics of modernism and postmodernism). An alternate take on this is the phrase's implication that our corners of the world aren't natural . . . not even for us, the very people who design and inhabit those spaces. It begs the question of where the boundary that demarcates the "natural world" is located and how we would know it. Thus, I'd argue, the very adjective "natural" makes the "natural world" unnatural: an artificial space, an abstraction.

My only real point in saying the above is that, at the level of observation--and not just scientific observation, either--adjectives such as "natural" aren't helpful. It creates situations such as the one Pam describes above: it causes the implicit assumption that humans are alien beings (shades of Scientology) or contaminants. Or, alternately, it creates situations such as those that Pooh and Piglet find themselves in: it causes the implicit assumption that the very world they move about in is a sort of petri dish that they observe from without.

How to get out of this bind? Well, get rid of the adjective. Adjectives are human judgments, human pronouncements--our tracks--and not, necessarily, words that actually describe what is/is not There. I hope no one misunderstands me to be saying something like, Well, then, there must not be any Nature, then, or Well, then, this must mean that we can do any old thing to any old part of the world, then, since we're no different, at base, from any other living thing here. Nope--just that adjectives are relative terms. They are human things. They aren't substantives, or verbs.

The world is the world, neither natural or un-, and there is what is done to/in it. Life is a web; all living things are enmeshed in it, all interacting with each other more or less directly, sometimes beneficially, sometimes not. One of those species in particular is adept at adapting to and/or modifying itself and/or its environment to suit its needs and wants, often to the detriment of other species and maybe, in the long term, to itself; but it's also shown itself in the past to be adept at recognizing detrimental behavior and, occasionally, changing for the better.

Yada, yada, yada, you say. Well, then, perhaps it would be a Good Thing to observe the world--and live in it--like it's "Yada, yada, yada."

UPDATE (January 9): Via 3 Quarks Daily comes some (Western) cultural context on this theme:
To understand physical reality seems to demand not only the renunciation of an anthropocentric or geocentric world view, but also a radical elimination of all anthropomorphic elements and principles, as they arise either from the world given to the five human senses or from the categories inherent in the human mind. The question assumes that man is the highest being we know of, an assumption which we have inherited from the Romans, whose humanitas was so alien to the Greeks’ frame of mind that they had not even a word for it. (The reason for the absence of the word humanitas from Greek language and thought was that the Greeks, in contrast to the Romans, never thought that man is the highest being there is. Aristotle calls this belief atopos, “absurd.”)[2] This view of man is even more alien to the scientist, to whom man is no more than a special case of organic life and to whom man’s habitat—the earth, together with earthbound laws—is no more than a special borderline case of absolute, universal laws, that is, laws that rule the immensity of the universe. Surely the scientist cannot permit himself to ask: What consequences will the result of my investigations have for the stature (or, for that matter, for the future) of man? It has been the glory of modern science that it has been able to emancipate itself completely from all such anthropocentric, that is, truly humanistic, concerns.

Also: If you're still interested in all this, do NOT miss Randall's posing of some important questions he was kind enough to say my post raised.

Read More...

Tuesday, October 02, 2007

A stretch of river XLIII: Wind and Wallace Stevens

This was going to be about the wind that Scruffy and I experienced and of the various roarings beneath the wind--traffic, airplanes, cooling units--and the indefinable Something that I could hear that was framing all this noise and motion. But as it happens, today is Wallace Stevens' birthday (thanks, Mr. Keillor), and Stevens was the sort of poet for whom wind is an important image. So: a favorite Stevens poem of mine in which wind figures prominently. (And a promise of a more substantial post soon.)


The Snow Man

One must have a mind of winter
To regard the frost and the boughs
Of the pine-trees crusted with snow;

And have been cold a long time
To behold the junipers shagged with ice,
The spruces rough in the distant glitter

Of the January sun; and not to think
Of any misery in the sound of the wind,
In the sound of a few leaves,

Which is the sound of the land
Full of the same wind
That is blowing in the same bare place

For the listener, who listens in the snow,
And, nothing himself, beholds
Nothing that is not there and the nothing that is.

Read More...

Monday, May 21, 2007

A stretch of river XXXIX: Updating the wildlife census, and some thoughts on this blog's epigraph

"Adam names the animals," from The Aberdeen Bestiary

This post's soundtrack, for what it's worth: Minimalist: Adams, Glass, Reich, Heath.

UPDATE (May 22): Appended to the end of this post, a round-up of links to other bloggers who have done more with Montague than just name-check him.

Almost a year ago (how time flies in the blogosphere), I posted a list of the larger fauna I've seen along my bend of the Little Arkansas. I've seen some things since then that compel me to revisit that list, and then announce the arrival of a new (to this area) species that, while exciting in its own right, also causes me to think about some Larger Issues.

First, the freshening up of the list: some time after I posted that list, I confirmed that the large water mammal I mentioned in the post was/is indeed a beaver. To the list of birds I can now add red-winged blackbirds, a male of which I saw a couple of weeks ago.

But now for the bigger news. I had first seen it yesterday morning but thought it a fluke; but this morning, too, in the park at sunrise, standing alone, proud, brazen and unafraid under a tree near the river in full view of the apartments on the other side, the dawn's rays revealing it in all its glittering glory, I saw an empty shopping cart.

It's always the way, isn't it, that the very times you see something beautiful or extraordinary tend to be those times you happen to be without a camera; such, alas for my reader(s), is my and your plight this morning (and every morning, seeing as I don't own a digital camera). But we are not entirely without resources: I don't own a copy, but thanks to the glories of the Internets I have been able to consult that award-winning taxonomical work, The Stray Shopping Carts of Eastern North America: A Guide to Field Identification by Julian Montague. Well, okay: actually, I've been consulting his website. Whatever.

Below the fold, a foray into the delights of shopping-cart taxonomy and some musings on same.

Read the following and tell me we could not use a few good Montagues up there in Washington:

Until now, the major obstacle that has prevented people from thinking critically about stray shopping carts has been that we have not had any formalized language to differentiate one shopping cart from another.

In order to encourage a more nuanced and comprehensive understanding of the phenomenon, I have worked for the past six years to develop a system of identification for stray shopping carts.

None of this unsophisticated black/white, us/them kind of thinking. "Nuanced and comprehensive": that's the ticket.

Here's a quick sketching out of Montague's taxonomy's organizing principle. He prefers not to dwell on descriptions of physical attributes but, instead, on the cart's physical location and condition relative to its provenance. Thus his division of carts into Class A: False Strays and Class B: True Strays. You know you want to go there, as the kids say these days, so I'll not tell you here what I know you'll see there. Instead, I'll cut to the chase and say that, within Montague's current system, the cart I saw most closely corresponds to either B/16 (Edge Marginalization) or B/21 (Naturalization).

Except that it doesn't.

Given its solitude and the fact that, from a distance (I didn't want to approach out of fear of startling it) it appeared to be completely empty, I don't think what I saw was a stray. I think it was a feral shopping cart. It's gone wild.

Just read again my description of the cart above and see if it doesn't eerily echo this, the penultimate paragraph of Jack London's wonderful novel, The Call of the Wild:

It is a great, gloriously glittering shopping cart, like, and yet unlike, all other shopping carts. He rolls in alone from the neighborhood and comes down into an open space among the trees in the park. Here a stream of refuse flows from torn plastic shopping bags and sinks into the ground, with long grasses growing through it and flies swarming it and hiding it from the sun; and here he muses for a time on those shopping bags, wheels squeaking once, long and mournfully, ere he departs.


(So I, um, photoshopped it a bit. Big wup.)

I am so excited about the possibility that through my sighting I may actually have created the need for a Class C designation--or at the very least a serious rethinking of the Class B categories--that I have actually written Mr. Montague to seek his counsel in this matter. If and when this 21st-century Linnaeus deigns to answer me, I'll be certain to post his reply here. But. You know how scientists are. They want to be right, but they also want to be first. So, even though I'll be the first to admit that good old Blog Meridian isn't exactly a juried journal, I felt it crucial to my reader(s) (not to mention my not-inconsiderable ego) to find some outlet for making known my sighting before all those wannabe Roger Tory Peterson-types of the shopping-cart-watching world try to gain credit. Here: I'll even name the sucker: Meridian's Feral Cart. It's Google-able now, or soon will be: as good as carved in stone, and the temptation is strong to make it Wikipedia-able. My own little case study of truthiness. And if it turns out later that I'm wrong, that, in Mr. Montague's considered opinion it is in fact merely a True Stray, well, that's what retractions are for.

One complicating factor in all this: in the title of his book Montague specifies that this is a taxonomy for eastern North America. If the book--er, the website--has a weakness, it's that Montague doesn't talk about ranges; thus, I can't be sure if Kansas qualifies as "eastern North America." On his site I did see a picture of a stray cart taken in Hawaii, which doesn't strike me as being especially "eastern" . . . or "North American," for that matter. More "Pacific" or "Oceania," if you ask me. But I recognize that, only six years on, Montague's taxonomy is a work in progress. Linnaeus worked on his for around 40 years.

Behind Montague's work is an underlying serious metaphysical notion, of course: the very human need to make sense of experience via some sort of ordering schema--like telling stories about them--in order to know (that is, begin to inhabit) the world. Taxonomies require a sort of language--indeed, their very ordering principles are themselves a sort of grammar. Not quite narratives themselves, they are more like settings within which narratives (evolution, for example) can occur. More pertinent for this post, though, is that these maps and languages don't merely describe the world, they are what make it manifest, give it a shape and dimensions that we can begin to convey to another. In the beginning is the Word. As Montague suggests above, you have to have words, a system, before you can begin to talk about things.

Scientists, confined as they are, poor souls, to the material and measurable, cannot talk about this sort of truth. Poets can, though; one of them, Wallace Stevens, took up as his one great theme that intersection of the observable world and the human desire/need to impose an intellectual order on that world, and the problem that we can never truly know, with absolute certainty, where the one ends and the other begins. His grand poem, "The Idea of Order at Key West," has nary a shopping cart in sight. Yet as the woman through her song sings this sunset and the beach at Key West into existence, we can also recognize, not entirely sarcastically, Julian Montague in this, the latter half of the poem:
It was her voice that made
The sky acutest at its vanishing.
She measured to the hour its solitude.
She was the single artificer of the world
In which she sang. And when she sang, the sea,
Whatever self it had, became the self
That was her song, for she was the maker. Then we,
As we beheld her striding there alone,
Knew that there never was a world for her
Except the one she sang and, singing, made.

Ramon Fernandez, tell me, if you know,
Why, when the singing ended and we turned
Toward the town, tell why the glassy lights,
The lights in the fishing boats at anchor there,
As the night descended, tilting in the air,
Mastered the night and portioned out the sea,
Fixing emblazoned zones and fiery poles,
Arranging, deepening, enchanting night.

Oh! Blessed rage for order, pale Ramon,
The maker's rage to order words of the sea,
Words of the fragrant portals, dimly-starred,
And of ourselves and of our origins,
In ghostlier demarcations, keener sounds.

I can't blame you if you've never scrolled down to the bottom of this blog, so I'll spare you the trouble and tell you that you'll find there the the first five words of the first line of the final stanza. A poet wrote those words, but we all live them anytime, literally, we look at and think about the world. Does order exist in the world independent of our perceiving it, or is our rage for order such that we invent it, seeing the world via a lens of our making? Oddly enough, thinking about shopping carts is a good starting place for engaging with this question.

UPDATE:
Literally just as I was about to push the "Publish Post" button, I decided to check my e-mail, and wouldn't you know . . .

Thank you for your interest,

It sounds like your cart could be B/15 Gap Marginalization. A park is not a "gap space" under the present definition, but the cart might have been placed there in a B/15 kind of way. B/1 Open True includes carts in parks in its definition. It is a safe choice since all True Stray carts are by definition also B/1.

Cheers,

Julian

Having heard from this great man, I am far richer now than I once was. I hope you can say the same. Oh: and I retract all that "feral" stuff above . . . though, I think on that cart, out there running proud and alone, and I do feel its wildness in my bones . . .

APPENDIX: More shopping-cart truthiness:

Gwynne of The Shallow End kindly links to this post, for which I'm most grateful. But she makes a claim there that frankly set off my Truthiness Detector: "You won't find this anyplace else in the blogosphere."

What follows is Gwynne's fault.

Most of the 355 hits that "Montague stray shopping carts blogspot" produced on Google (of which, by the way, this post is #1) were quickie mentions of Montague's book in conjunction with the Oddest Book Title award (unless, buried among the not-so-surprising number of hits on German-language blogs (that whole "VE musht hav' ORDEHR!!!" thing, you know) there are some entries like mine). Below, though, are some places that to a greater (considerably so) or lesser extent engage with Montague's work, a version of it, or with the man himself. A couple of these blogs are actually worth a return visit, especially for the hordes of shopping-cart-taxonomists among you (and if you've read this far, you'll want to at least entertain the possibility that you are among them . . . and/or seek some off-line counseling).

There actually exists a blog called Shopping Carts in Ravines (subtitled "free lifestyles, fringe culture, and delicious home cookin'). This post sketches out Montague's work . . . and then mentions his/her own taxonomy. That one exists is curious enough; but two?

Um . . . make that three, or perhaps 2.5, seeing as Toronto's Abused Shopping Carts' preoccupation is pretty clearly indicated in its title.

At Oly's musings on life, art, individuality, there's a post from March that delves more deeply into the particulars of Montague's taxonomy but does, in passing, contain a lament for shopping carts that have met their demise as well as a reminiscence of his/her halcyon days as a student when "commandeering" shopping carts to aid in moves. Waltons-esque in its mood, lacking only the plaintive harmonica and glockenspiel.

Roam Buffalo has a very brief interview with Montague, focusing on working as a designer in Buffalo, NY.

Therefore, I_blog has a brief review of Montague's book. It's positive, but I do take issue with RPA's claim that "it really seems to be just" (my emphasis) a way to market some photographs. Would I have taken Montague's work so to heart as I have if all it's intended to do is sell some pics? Wait, don't answer that . . .

And showing up in my e-mail this morning via Camille of 327 Market is the search for "shopping carts" that she ran on her artist-friend's blog, My Droppings.

UPDATE II (May 23, 2007):
The dialogue continues.

As a serendipitous tangential response to Pam's comment below, in this morning's e-mail I received this from Julian (yes--we're on a first-name basis now; I sense my reader(s) seething with envy):

John,

The System is set up so that there can be no "feral" carts every cart
can
be classified in one way or another. As far as geographical range, even
though the book specifies Eastern North America, I am pretty confident
that the System will work for the whole country and most of Western
Europe. It would have been nice to have some shots of the Prarie [sic] in
there.

Cheers,

Julian

I'll let this stand as the last word for now. But I look forward to returning to this subject as the occasion presents itself.

And if you've read this far, I truly am grateful for that.

Read More...